Argentina bounced back from their opening-round defeat to Scotland with a convincing 35-21 victory over Wales at Estadio San Juan del Bicentenario in Round 2 of the Nations Championship. Number eight Joaquin Oviedo scored twice as Los Pumas produced a dominant five-try display, mixing close-range power with penetrating running through a porous Welsh defence. Wales had struck first through captain Dewi Lake, but Argentina’s pace and physicality proved too much as the hosts secured a bonus-point victory before half-time.
Key moments
4 mins – TRY WALES: Dewi Lake powers over from a driving maul after Wales win the lineout 5m out. Sam Costelow converts. (Argentina 0-7 Wales)
6 mins – TRY ARGENTINA: Joaquin Oviedo crashes over after Santiago Carreras breaks down the left and links with Mateo Carreras. Gonzalo Garcia provides the final pass. Tomas Albornoz converts. (Argentina 7-7 Wales)
15 mins – TRY ARGENTINA: Justo Piccardo finishes in the corner after Bautista Delguy claims a brilliant aerial take above Sam Costelow on the 22. The ball is moved swiftly through Mateo Carreras. Albornoz converts from the sideline. (Argentina 14-7 Wales)
23 mins – DISALLOWED TRY WALES: Jac Morgan appears to score after sustained forward pressure near the Argentine line, but referee Paul Williams rules Morgan was bound to the ruck before picking up the ball. Wales awarded a penalty.
24 mins – TRY WALES: Rhys Carre barges over from close range after a quick tap penalty. Tomos Williams provides the assist. Costelow converts. (Argentina 14-14 Wales)
34 mins – TRY ARGENTINA: Marcos Kremer peels off the back of a driving maul and crashes over from close range after Argentina win a lineout 5m out. Albornoz converts. (Argentina 21-14 Wales)
39 mins – TRY ARGENTINA: Santiago Carreras finishes off sustained Pumas pressure in the Welsh 22, crossing on the left after the forwards create an overlap. Albornoz converts. (Argentina 28-14 Wales)
Half-time: Argentina 28-14 Wales. Argentina controlled the half after Wales’ dream start through Dewi Lake’s early try. Los Pumas’ pace and power proved the difference, with Oviedo, Piccardo, Kremer and Carreras all crossing. Wales fought hard through Carre’s try but conceded two quickfire scores before the break.
48 mins – TRY ARGENTINA: Joaquin Oviedo dives over for his second after Santiago Carreras breaks into the Welsh 22 and delivers a superb offload. Albornoz converts. (Argentina 35-14 Wales)
56 mins – DISALLOWED TRY ARGENTINA: Matias Moroni scoops up a loose ball to score, but TMO review reveals a knock-on by Simon Benitez Cruz in the build-up. Jac Morgan penalised for offside.
67 mins – TRY WALES: Ben Warren drives over from close range after sustained pressure from a lineout. Tomos Williams sets up the score. Costelow converts. (Argentina 35-21 Wales)
Full-time: Argentina 35-21 Wales
Wales flew to San Juan hunting a third consecutive Test victory for the first time since the 2023 World Cup, but this was always going to be a different proposition to the Fiji win in Cardiff. Argentina, stung by their 47-38 defeat to Scotland in Cordoba, made five changes and arrived at Estadio San Juan del Bicentenario with a point to prove. Lock Guido Petti marked his 100th cap by leading the side out, but it was Wales who drew first blood in a frenetic opening.
Steve Tandy made three changes of his own, with Sam Costelow replacing Dan Edwards at fly-half, Ellis Mee starting on the wing ahead of Louis Rees-Zammit, and James Botham coming in at blindside flanker. The selection raised eyebrows, particularly the decision to bench Rees-Zammit, but Tandy pointed to the travel demands and a minor niggle picked up before the Fiji match.
The visitors struck with barely three minutes on the clock. Ellis Mee tapped down a Tomos Williams box kick on the Argentine 22, and Wales set up a lineout 10 metres from the line. Having scored three driving maul tries against Fiji the previous week, they conjured a fourth as Lake was driven over to give Wales the dream start. Costelow added the extras, but the lead lasted just two minutes.
Argentina responded with a flowing move that showcased their backline threat. Santiago Carreras broke down the left and linked with Mateo Carreras, whose surge was halted only by a brilliant last-ditch tackle from Eddie James. The reprieve was momentary. The hosts kept the ball alive and Oviedo arrived at pace to take a pass from Garcia and power over for his sixth international try. Albornoz converted to level proceedings.
Los Pumas seized the initiative again on 15 minutes when Bautista Delguy produced a moment of brilliance. The wing towered above Costelow to claim an attacking high ball, offloading in one motion. The ball was shifted swiftly through Mateo Carreras before Piccardo evaded James’ tackle and crossed in the corner. Albornoz converted superbly from the touchline to make it 14-7.
Wales were being forced to defend desperately and put in 117 tackles during the first half alone, but they managed to convert a spell of sustained pressure midway through the opening period. Adam Beard and Dillon Lewis won turnovers, and when the penalty came, Costelow kicked to the corner. Morgan appeared to have crashed over from close range, only for a lengthy TMO review to rule the try out, with the flanker adjudged to have been bound to the ruck before picking up the ball.
Wales did not panic. From the resulting penalty, Lake tapped quickly and drove for the line before Williams whipped out a pass to Carre on the charge. The Saracens loosehead powered over under the posts for his fifth try in six internationals, a remarkable record that has made him one of Wales’ most potent attacking weapons. Costelow converted to make it 14-14 with just over half an hour played.
The momentum, however, shifted decisively in Argentina’s favour. Incessant pressure and a series of Welsh penalties allowed Los Pumas to set up camp inside the 22. From a five-metre lineout, Kremer peeled off the back of the driving maul and crashed over on 34 minutes. Albornoz converted, and Argentina were not finished. Five minutes later, the forwards did the hard work before creating an overlap out wide. Santiago Carreras strolled over virtually untouched to secure the bonus-point try before half-time. At 28-14, Los Pumas had seized complete control.
Argentina emerged for the second half with the same intensity and struck within eight minutes of the restart. Piccardo ran a powerful line into the Welsh 22 before turning the ball infield. Santiago Carreras provided a superb offload, and Oviedo was on hand to dive over for his second of the afternoon. Albornoz converted to extend the lead to 21 points, and the contest appeared all but over.
Replacement Matias Moroni thought he had added a sixth try when he scooped up a loose ball to cross, but the TMO intervened for the second time, identifying a knock-on by Benitez Cruz in the build-up. Morgan was penalised for offside, but Argentina were unable to capitalise from the resulting penalty as the Welsh defence held firm on the goal line, with Pablo Matera held up over the whitewash.
Wales captain Lake was forced from the field with a limp in the 57th minute, with Ryan Elias coming on to win his 50th cap. Tandy continued to unload his bench, bringing on Rees-Zammit, Max Llewellyn, and Teddy Williams, while Exeter back-rower Kane James entered the fray to win his first cap in place of Aaron Wainwright, who had himself made his Test debut in San Juan eight years earlier.
James had barely been on the field when Warren, winning just his second cap after debuting against Fiji, crashed over for his first international try. The score came from a five-metre lineout, with the Ospreys prop eventually taking a scoring pass on the outside from Williams. Costelow’s conversion brought Wales back to within 14 points at 35-21, and the tourists pressed hard in the closing stages for a further try that would have secured a losing bonus point.
They came agonisingly close, breaking out from deep inside their own 22 with the clock in the red, but a knock-on just as space appeared ended their hopes. Rees-Zammit complained of an off-the-ball challenge that went unpenalised, but Argentina held firm to close out a convincing victory.
“We started well scoring an early try, but we dropped off,” Lake said afterwards. “They were more physical than us and they beat us in that battle. I don’t think structure is the problem, it’s the physical element. We were dropping off too many tackles. We have to work harder and be quicker.”
Try-scorer Carre acknowledged the setback but urged perspective. “Argentina had a better performance than they did last week and we probably took a step back compared to Fiji, so it was ultimately disappointing,” the loosehead said. “We are still building and have produced some good performances lately, with three in a row before this, so while it is a setback we knew it was going to be a long journey. Argentina are a great team and if you aren’t at 100% then they are probably going to get the best of you.”
Argentina captain Julian Montoya paid tribute to the Welsh effort while acknowledging his side’s improvement. “We knew that Wales were going to be tough and a quality side,” Montoya said. “They’re getting better and better and we knew they were never going to go away. We got better in a lot of things and we’re really proud of getting the win.”
The result means Argentina have their first victory in the Nations Championship after two rounds, while Wales’ mini revival has been brought to a halt. Tandy will take some positives from the performance, not least the continued potency of the driving maul and Carre’s remarkable try-scoring record, but the defensive frailties and inability to match Argentina’s physicality across the gain line will concern him greatly.
The challenge only gets harder from here. Wales travel to Durban to face world champions South Africa on Saturday, a fixture that will test Tandy’s squad to its absolute limit after a long and draining season. Argentina, meanwhile, remain at home and head to Santiago del Estero to host England in what promises to be another compelling Nations Championship encounter.
Teams
Argentina: 15 Santiago Carreras, 14 Bautista Delguy, 13 Lucio Cinti, 12 Justo Piccardo, 11 Mateo Carreras, 10 Tomas Albornoz, 9 Gonzalo Garcia, 8 Joaquin Oviedo, 7 Marcos Kremer, 6 Santiago Grondona, 5 Matias Alemanno, 4 Guido Petti, 3 Tomas Rapetti, 2 Julian Montoya (c), 1 Boris Wenger.
Replacements: 16 Ignacio Ruiz, 17 Mayco Vivas, 18 Francisco Coria Marchetti, 19 Franco Molina, 20 Pablo Matera, 21 Simon Benitez Cruz, 22 Matias Moroni, 23 Ignacio Mendy.
Wales: 15 Blair Murray, 14 Ellis Mee, 13 Eddie James, 12 Joe Hawkins, 11 Josh Adams, 10 Sam Costelow, 9 Tomos Williams, 8 Aaron Wainwright, 7 Jac Morgan, 6 James Botham, 5 Adam Beard, 4 Ben Carter, 3 Dillon Lewis, 2 Dewi Lake (c), 1 Rhys Carre.
Replacements: 16 Ryan Elias, 17 Nicky Smith, 18 Ben Warren, 19 Teddy Williams, 20 Kane James, 21 Kieran Hardy, 22 Max Llewellyn, 23 Louis Rees-Zammit.
Match details
Argentina 35 (Tries: Oviedo 2, Piccardo, Kremer, S. Carreras; Conversions: Albornoz 5/5)
Wales 21 (Tries: Lake, Carre, Warren; Conversions: Costelow 3/3)
Half-time: 28-14
Venue: Estadio San Juan del Bicentenario, San Juan
Referee: Paul Williams (New Zealand)