England survived a chaotic second half featuring seven yellow cards, a penalty try and a dramatic last-minute TMO decision to beat Argentina 31-24 in Santiago del Estero and finish their summer tour with back-to-back victories.
Key moments
4 mins – TRY ENGLAND: Fin Smith floats a perfect cross-kick to the right wing, where Tommy Freeman wins the aerial contest over Santiago Carreras and touches down in the corner. Fin Smith misses the conversion. (Argentina 0-5 England)
24 mins – TRY ENGLAND: Joe Heyes wins a loose ball and Immanuel Feyi-Waboso bursts through two tacklers to break into the 22, finding Ben Earl in support on his right shoulder. Earl holds off Tomas Albornoz to score. Fin Smith converts. (Argentina 0-12 England)
24 mins – YELLOW CARD ARGENTINA: Mateo Carreras shown yellow for head contact on Tommy Freeman. Referred by TMO Brett Cronan.
30 mins – PENALTY ARGENTINA: Tomas Albornoz slots from right of the posts after Jamie George penalised for obstruction. (Argentina 3-12 England)
33 mins – TRY ENGLAND: England’s scrum demolishes the Argentine pack, walking them back over their own try line. Earl controls at the base and dots down for his second. Fin Smith converts. (Argentina 3-19 England)
Half-time: Argentina 3-19 England. A dominant first-half display from England, who matched ambition with a statement set piece. Immanuel Feyi-Waboso was electric with ball in hand, while Ben Earl crossed twice. Argentina’s only points came via an Albornoz penalty, with the hosts struggling for any cohesion in attack.
43 mins – TRY ARGENTINA: Argentina maul close to the line, Gonzalo Garcia bursts for the try line and is stopped just short. Mateo Carreras, fresh from the sin bin, drives through Fin Smith to score. Albornoz converts. (Argentina 10-19 England)
50 mins – YELLOW CARD ENGLAND: Jack van Poortvliet shown yellow for deliberate knock-on, slapping down an Albornoz pass inside the 22.
55 mins – PENALTY TRY ARGENTINA / YELLOW CARD ENGLAND: Tomas Albornoz bursts through and is brought down two metres short. As he offloads, Alex Coles swipes the ball away with Pablo Matera in close support. Penalty try awarded and Coles sent to the sin bin. England reduced to 13. (Argentina 17-19 England)
60 mins – YELLOW CARD ARGENTINA: Joaquin Oviedo shown yellow for a dangerous cleanout on Guy Pepper.
62 mins – TRY ENGLAND: Jack van Poortvliet, just back from the sin bin, fires a sharp pass wide to Marcus Smith, who dives over in the right corner. Santiago Carreras attempted to intercept but couldn’t prevent the score. Fin Smith converts superbly from the touchline. (Argentina 17-26 England)
63 mins – YELLOW CARD ARGENTINA: Santiago Carreras shown yellow for the deliberate knock-on attempt on van Poortvliet’s pass.
69 mins – TRY ENGLAND: Argentina’s lineout is overthrown and England seize possession. Van Poortvliet sends the ball left and Feyi-Waboso slices through two defenders from 30 metres out for a stunning solo try. Fin Smith misses the conversion. (Argentina 17-31 England)
73 mins – YELLOW CARD ENGLAND: Henry Pollock sent to the sin bin for repeated team offsides.
77 mins – YELLOW CARD ENGLAND: Emmanuel Iyogun, on debut, shown yellow for cynical offside. England reduced to 13 for the closing minutes.
79 mins – INJURY: Benhard Janse van Rensburg knocked unconscious making a tackle and stretchered from the field.
80 mins – TRY ARGENTINA: Justo Piccardo bursts through a gap and runs to the posts. Albornoz converts with a quick drop-goal style kick. (Argentina 24-31 England)
83 mins – NO TRY (TMO): Bautista Delguy dives for the right corner under pressure from Noah Caluori and Henry Slade. Referee Angus Gardner gives try on field but TMO Brett Cronan rules the ball was grounded on the intersection of the sideline and the try line simultaneously. No try. Argentina denied the chance to convert and draw the match. Full-time whistle follows.
Full-time: Argentina 24-31 England
Match report
It had been a big week already for international sport between these two nations, and this was a contest that delivered drama to match anything that preceded it. Three days after England’s footballers suffered World Cup semi-final heartbreak at Argentina’s hands, Steve Borthwick’s rugby side came through their own ordeal in Santiago del Estero, surviving a second-half disciplinary meltdown to complete an eventful five-try victory.
Argentina had set the tone before a ball was kicked by taking the field in replica shirts from the 1986 World Cup, the dark blue kit synonymous with Diego Maradona’s infamous Hand of God goal against England. The Estadio Unico Madre de Ciudades, where a statue of Maradona stands outside the ground, was rocking before kick-off as the nationalist anthem La Cuarta Estrella rang around the stands. Tears streamed down the faces of the Argentine players during their national anthem, underlining the emotional intensity of the occasion.
England, though, refused to be rattled. Inside four minutes, Fin Smith executed an inch-perfect cross-kick to the right wing and Tommy Freeman rose superbly above Santiago Carreras to claim the ball and touch down in the corner. There were immediate handbags in the in-goal area, with Ollie Chessum penalised for charging in from distance, but the early statement had been made.
From there, the visitors grew in authority. Immanuel Feyi-Waboso was electric every time he touched the ball, repeatedly punching holes in the Argentine defensive line. His surge through three defenders in midfield on 24 minutes created the opportunity for Ben Earl, who took the offload in support and used his considerable strength to power over. Fin Smith converted, and when Mateo Carreras was shown a yellow card for a high tackle on Freeman moments later, England’s grip on the contest tightened further.
Argentina could find no answers. Their attack was pedestrian, with players static and running the wrong channels. England’s defence, marshalled superbly by Henry Slade in the 13 channel, strangled every Pumas foray. The dominance was emphatically underlined on 33 minutes when England’s scrum, with Joe Heyes and Ellis Genge both prominent, splintered their Argentine counterparts and walked them back over their own try line for Earl to dot down unopposed. Smith converted and at 19-3, the contest appeared all but settled.
The second half, however, was a different match entirely. Argentina came out transformed after the interval, with fly-half Tomas Albornoz the chief catalyst. His chip and chase through midfield on the first attacking play set the tone, and within four minutes the Pumas had their first try as Carreras, back from the sin bin, drove through Fin Smith to finish off strong mauling work. Albornoz converted and the gap was down to nine.
Then England’s discipline, which has been a recurring theme throughout 2026, unravelled spectacularly. Van Poortvliet was shown yellow on 50 minutes for slapping down an Albornoz pass with one hand, and five minutes later Coles was sent to join him after swiping at a pop pass near the line with Matera in close support. Gardner had no option but to award a penalty try and brandish the yellow card. At 17-19, with England temporarily reduced to 13 men and Marcus Smith filling in at scrum-half after Fin Smith had been removed for a head injury assessment, the visitors were in genuine crisis.
The home crowd sensed blood, roaring their side forward. But England’s remaining players dug in with remarkable resolve. Chessum, who had assumed the captaincy after Jamie George’s departure, organised the defensive effort superbly. A crucial lineout steal from Chessum, reading the call of his former Leicester teammate Julian Montoya, relieved the pressure at a critical moment.
Then came the turning point. Oviedo was shown yellow for a dangerous cleanout on Pepper on the hour mark, and within two minutes the returned van Poortvliet had fired a long pass to Marcus Smith for a try in the right corner. Fin Smith, back from his HIA, converted superbly from the touchline. Santiago Carreras was then also sin-binned for a deliberate knock-on on the pass that created Smith’s try, and England had breathing room once more.
Feyi-Waboso’s try on 69 minutes was the moment that effectively sealed the victory, and arguably the score of the match. Argentina overthrew their lineout and England pounced. The ball was moved left and Feyi-Waboso, cutting a gorgeous angle, sliced through two defenders from 30 metres to score a try of the highest quality. At 31-17, surely England were safe.
They were not. Yellow cards for Pollock and debutant Iyogun reduced England to 13 for the closing minutes, and Piccardo’s 80th-minute try brought Argentina back to within seven. The restart was gathered by Argentina and what followed was three minutes of pure theatre. The Pumas worked through more than 20 phases before the ball was shipped wide to Delguy on the right wing. He dived for the corner and Gardner gave the try on field, only for TMO Cronan to overrule him, judging the ball had been grounded on the intersection of the sideline and the try line. Slade’s covering tackle had been the decisive intervention. Argentina’s players were furious. Gardner was surrounded. The whistle finally blew.
“It was a tough fought match that went right to the end,” said player of the match Feyi-Waboso. “Argentina, the passion, the fans, the atmosphere was amazing. Our discipline wasn’t great but we managed to hold on at the end. I don’t know how many cards there were in that game, but it is too many. You can’t be finishing games with 13 men.”
Captain George, who had led the side through a gruelling three-week tour spanning three continents, was proud but honest about the failings. “The way that we rallied, the way that we got around each other, the way that we fought when we went down to 13 twice was brilliant,” he said. “We made life so hard for ourselves again in terms of dropping down to 13. I think a lot of it goes down to the amount of pressure that Argentina put us under. They’re a brilliant team. Winning here in Argentina is very, very difficult.”
Borthwick dismissed his critics in typically combative fashion. “I’m delighted for the players. They showed incredible spirit,” he said. “It’s almost unfair to pull out one example but Henry Slade’s tackle at the end was incredible. It shows the fight that’s in this group of players, as well as their togetherness and connection.”
The head coach was less receptive to questions about England’s discipline, which now stands at 14 yellow cards and one red in eight matches in 2026. “I don’t think now is the time to be digging into that,” he said. “This team has done really, really well. It was a tough Test match, a fantastic Test match, we scored some wonderful tries and as ever you guys concentrate on the negativity. You’re like the negativity committee so it’s lovely coming and talking to you again.”
There was a spicy postscript as Argentina head coach Felipe Contepomi cut his post-match press conference short, taking exception to the music and celebrations audible from England’s dressing room next door and accusing them of showing a “lack of respect”. Argentina captain Julian Montoya took a more measured approach. “We always respect the ref. It’s part of our values,” he said. “We respect the decision. Of course I’m a bit frustrated but it is what it is.”
The victory extends England’s winning run against Argentina to six matches under Borthwick and moves them up to third in the Nations Championship Northern Hemisphere table, behind France and Scotland. They return to action in November with home fixtures against Australia, New Zealand and Japan at Allianz Stadium. For now, after 25,000 air miles in three weeks, Borthwick’s squad have earned their summer break – though the discipline question will follow them all the way to the World Cup.
Teams
Argentina: 15 Santiago Carreras, 14 Bautista Delguy, 13 Matias Moroni, 12 Justo Piccardo, 11 Mateo Carreras, 10 Tomas Albornoz, 9 Gonzalo Garcia, 8 Joaquin Oviedo, 7 Marcos Kremer, 6 Santiago Grondona, 5 Matias Alemanno, 4 Guido Petti, 3 Tomas Rapetti, 2 Julian Montoya (captain), 1 Mayco Vivas.
Replacements: 16 Ignacio Ruiz, 17 Boris Wenger, 18 Pedro Delgado, 19 Efrain Elias, 20 Pablo Matera, 21 Joaquin Moro, 22 Simon Benitez Cruz, 23 Lucio Cinti.
England: 15 Marcus Smith, 14 Tommy Freeman, 13 Henry Slade, 12 Seb Atkinson, 11 Immanuel Feyi-Waboso, 10 Fin Smith, 9 Jack van Poortvliet, 8 Ben Earl, 7 Guy Pepper, 6 Ollie Chessum, 5 George Martin, 4 Alex Coles, 3 Joe Heyes, 2 Jamie George (captain), 1 Ellis Genge.
Replacements: 16 Luke Cowan-Dickie, 17 Emmanuel Iyogun, 18 George Kloska, 19 Tom Curry, 20 Henry Pollock, 21 Ben Spencer, 22 Benhard Janse van Rensburg, 23 Noah Caluori.
Match details
Argentina 24 (Tries: M. Carreras, Penalty Try, Piccardo; Conversions: Albornoz 2/2; Penalties: Albornoz 1/1)
England 31 (Tries: Freeman, Earl 2, M. Smith, Feyi-Waboso; Conversions: F. Smith 3/5)
Half-time: 3-19
Venue: Estadio Unico Madre de Ciudades, Santiago del Estero
Referee: Angus Gardner (Australia)