Steve Borthwick has responded to England’s alarming Six Nations slump with the most radical selection overhaul in championship history, naming an entirely new backline and making nine personnel changes for Saturday’s clash with Italy at the Stadio Olimpico.
Key team news:
- Nine personnel changes – the most ever made by England between Six Nations matches
- Fin Smith returns at fly-half with George Ford dropped from the matchday 23 entirely
- Entirely new backline with no combination having played together at Test level
- Ben Earl wins his 50th cap at number eight
- Tommy Freeman moves from wing to outside centre; Seb Atkinson starts at inside centre
- Only Maro Itoje, Ellis Genge and Joe Heyes retain the same jerseys from the Ireland defeat
The dramatic shake-up represents the most changes ever made by England between Six Nations matches since the tournament expanded in 2000, surpassing the previous record of eight changes made by Brian Ashton before the 2007 victory over France following that year’s Croke Park humiliation.
Fin Smith returns at fly-half for his first start since the autumn, with George Ford dropped from the matchday 23 entirely after underwhelming performances in defeats to Scotland and Ireland. The 23-year-old Northampton playmaker, a British and Irish Lion, will marshal an entirely reshuffled backline in which not a single unit has previously played together at Test level.
“We’re expecting a big test in Rome and it’s one the players are really looking forward to,” said Borthwick. “We know the challenge Italy will bring at the Stadio Olimpico, and we’ve selected a team we believe will deliver the level of performance we’re striving for.”
Tommy Freeman is the sole survivor from the 42-21 defeat to Ireland but has been relocated from wing to outside centre, where he started the first two rounds before injury to Ollie Lawrence. Gloucester’s Seb Atkinson earns his third cap at inside centre, reuniting with Smith in a partnership that dates back to their days together at Worcester Warriors before the club’s collapse in 2022.
Elliot Daly returns at full-back, bringing 74 caps of experience to a back three completed by Tom Roebuck and Cadan Murley on the wings. Freddie Steward, who was replaced before half-time against Ireland as England fell 22-0 behind, has been dropped along with Henry Arundell and Fraser Dingwall.
Ben Spencer starts at scrum-half in place of the injured Alex Mitchell, who has been ruled out for the remainder of the tournament with a hamstring problem. Lawrence is also unavailable due to a knee injury sustained against Ireland.
The forward pack sees three changes, with Jamie George returning at hooker in place of Luke Cowan-Dickie, whose set-piece struggles contributed to England’s line-out malfunction against Ireland. Alex Coles partners captain Maro Itoje in the second row, while Guy Pepper reclaims the blindside flanker jersey he occupied in the opening two rounds.
Ben Earl, who moves back to number eight with Tom Curry shifting to openside, will win his 50th cap for England. The Saracens forward made his debut against Scotland in 2020 and has established himself as one of England’s most consistent performers.
“To reach 50 caps for England speaks volumes about Ben’s professionalism and the consistency of his performances,” said Borthwick. “He’s an important leader within this group, someone who drives standards and brings energy every day. It’s a wonderful achievement and one he should be very proud of.”
Henry Pollock, who made his first Test start against Ireland, drops to the bench alongside the demoted Cowan-Dickie and Ollie Chessum. Marcus Smith provides cover at fly-half and full-back, with Jack van Poortvliet the reserve scrum-half.
The scale of the overhaul means only three players retain the same jerseys they wore against Ireland: captain Itoje, and props Ellis Genge and Joe Heyes. Borthwick was unequivocal about his reasons for wielding the axe so dramatically.
“All of us have been really disappointed with the performances in the last two games,” he said. “Clearly there are some key aspects that weren’t good enough. Those have been addressed.
“I say to the team that we have certain standards and I’m going to hold them to those standards. There are certain things that, to me, are unwavering. Things that I will not move upon. Unfortunately, in the last two games, on certain things, we’ve not met those standards.”
The wholesale changes represent a significant gamble for Borthwick, whose regime has come under increasing scrutiny following back-to-back defeats that ended England’s title aspirations. Across those two matches, England conceded 73 points and missed 53 tackles while collecting four yellow cards.
England men’s football manager Thomas Tuchel visited the squad’s Pennyhill Park training base on Tuesday, continuing a pattern of cross-sport engagement that has previously included conversations with Gareth Southgate and Brendon McCullum.
“Expectation comes with the territory when you’re involved with English sport,” said Borthwick. “I’d much rather be involved with the team with expectation than the one without. We live in a society now where there are these extremes, there is this polarity. I can’t do anything about what’s outside, but what I can do is about what’s inside.”
Italy have never beaten England in 32 previous meetings stretching back 35 years, but Gonzalo Quesada’s side may sense an opportunity against an experimental opposition still licking their wounds. The Azzurri opened their campaign with victory over Scotland and pushed both Ireland and France hard in narrow defeats.
A defeat in Rome would leave England facing a trip to Paris in the final round needing a major upset against Grand Slam-chasing France to avoid a single-win championship campaign.
England team to face Italy:
15. Elliot Daly (Saracens, 74 caps)
14. Tom Roebuck (Sale Sharks, 10 caps)
13. Tommy Freeman (Northampton Saints, 25 caps)
12. Seb Atkinson (Gloucester Rugby, 2 caps)
11. Cadan Murley (Harlequins, 4 caps)
10. Fin Smith (Northampton Saints, 14 caps)
9. Ben Spencer (Bath Rugby, 16 caps)
1. Ellis Genge (Bristol Bears, 78 caps) – vice-captain
2. Jamie George (Saracens, 108 caps) – vice-captain
3. Joe Heyes (Leicester Tigers, 20 caps)
4. Maro Itoje (Saracens, 100 caps) – captain
5. Alex Coles (Northampton Saints, 17 caps)
6. Guy Pepper (Bath Rugby, 10 caps)
7. Tom Curry (Sale Sharks, 68 caps)
8. Ben Earl (Saracens, 49 caps)
Replacements:
16. Luke Cowan-Dickie (Sale Sharks, 56 caps)
17. Bevan Rodd (Sale Sharks, 13 caps)
18. Trevor Davison (Northampton Saints, 6 caps)
19. Ollie Chessum (Leicester Tigers, 33 caps)
20. Sam Underhill (Bath Rugby, 48 caps)
21. Henry Pollock (Northampton Saints, 8 caps)
22. Jack van Poortvliet (Leicester Tigers, 22 caps)
23. Marcus Smith (Harlequins, 48 caps)
Match details: Italy v England, Stadio Olimpico, Rome. Saturday 7 March, 4.40pm GMT.