In a thrilling encounter at Apia Park, Samoa staged a remarkable comeback to upset Italy 33-25 in their first Test match under new head coach Mase Mahonri Schwalger. The victory, which saw Samoa overturn a 10-point deficit, marked a successful start for both Schwalger and newly appointed captain Theo McFarland.
The match played in sweltering conditions on Friday, saw Samoa heavily lean on their Super Rugby Pacific experience, with eight Moana Pasifika players featured in the matchday squad. This strategy paid off, as the home side scored four tries to Italy’s three.
Italy, coming off an encouraging Six Nations campaign, started strongly. Winger Monty Ioane finished a long-range attack while Samoa fullback Duncan Paia’aua was in the sin-bin. Shortly after, debutant Matt Gallagher, son of former All Black John Gallagher, made his presence felt. Gallagher launched an attack that saw Ioane combine with Louis Lynagh, son of Australian rugby legend Michael Lynagh, for Italy’s second try.
Gallagher’s impact continued into the second half when his well-placed up-and-under led to a try for Paolo Garbisi, extending Italy’s lead to 25-15. The fullback’s performance showcased why coach Gonzalo Quesada had faith in handing him his first cap in such a challenging environment.
However, Samoa’s resilience shone through as the match progressed. Debutant flanker Murphy Taramai opened Samoa’s account, taking advantage of a gap in the Italian defence. Winger Nigel Ah Wong added another try before halftime, capitalizing on an Italian knock-on near their tryline to bring the score to 18-12 at the break.
The turning point came in the second half when Samoa dominated the final 30 minutes. Center Danny Toala found a corridor in the Italian defence to level the scores at 25-25. Fly-half D’Angelo Leuila’s accurate goal-kicking proved crucial, with three penalties in the second half pushing Samoa ahead.
The upset was sealed in the 77th minute when replacement Afa Moleli, one of five debutants for the home side, scored off a brilliant offload from hooker Samo Malolo. This final try showcased the depth and impact of Samoa’s bench, a factor that proved decisive in the humid conditions.
Throughout the match, Italy showed moments of defensive brilliance. Federico Ruzza made a try-saving tackle on Stacey Ili, while Alessandro Izekor’s interception denied Samo Malolo a certain try. However, these efforts weren’t enough to stem the Samoan comeback.
The result extends Italy’s winless streak in the Pacific islands, bringing their record against Samoa and Fiji to 0-8 in away fixtures. It also marks a promising start for Samoa, who hadn’t played since their group-stage exit in last year’s World Cup.
This upset victory sets a positive tone for Samoa as they prepare to host Spain next week, while Italy will look to bounce back in their upcoming matches against Tonga in Nuku’alofa and Japan in Tokyo.